• English

‘End the scourge of neglected tropical diseases’: UN health chief

In a statement released by WHO, Tedros Adhanom Ghebreyesus declared that a new approach is needed if diseases such as guinea worm and yaws are to be tackled: “This means injecting new energy into our efforts and working together in new ways to get prevention and treatment for all these diseases, to everyone who needs it”.

10-year plan

This new approach was unveiled on Wednesday, in a 10-year plan which targets a 90 per cent reduction in the need for the treatment of neglected tropical diseases (NTDs). The plan contains several concrete proposals in areas such as programme delivery, cost-effectiveness and improved coverage, and calls for programmes to be sustainable, with measurable outcomes and adequate domestic financing.

As well as causing pain and disability, NTDs hinder economic development, by preventing children from going to school and adults from going to work. Those affected by disabilities and impairments caused by NTDs, often experience stigma within their communities, leading to social isolation.

© UNICEF/Anne Ackerman
A young boy receives treatment for Guinea worm disease in South Sudan.

Ambitious targets

The WHO plan, developed in consultation with a wide selection of countries, partners, stakeholders, scientists, and academics, contains several ambitious targets, including the elimination of a minimum of one NTD in at least 100 countries, completely eradicating guinea worm and yaws, and vastly improving access to basic water supply and sanitation.

The progress made in fighting NTDs over the last ten years is an encouraging indicator of what can be achieved in the coming decade, the UN health agency said.

Around 600 million fewer people are now at risk of these diseases; 42 countries have eliminated at least one NTD; and global programmes treated at least one billion people in the five year period between 2015 and 2020.

Significant threats still need to be overcome, however, including climate change, the threat of new diseases crossing over from animals to humans, conflict, and continued inequalities in access to healthcare services, adequate housing, safe water and sanitation.

COVID-19: Prioritize school meals in plans to reopen classrooms, UN report says

The study found 370 million children worldwide, many of whom rely on school meals as a key source of their daily nutrition, have missed 40 per cent of in-school meals, on average, since the crisis began.   

The authors warned this looming nutrition crisis could put a whole generation at risk.  

Reliable nutrition 

“Despite clear evidence that schools are not primary drivers of COVID-19 infections, millions of children are facing school closures around the world”, said Henrietta Fore, UNICEF Executive Director.  

“Children who depend on schools for their daily meals are not only losing out on an education but also on a reliable source of nutrition.  As we respond to the COVID-19 pandemic and await vaccine distribution, we must prioritize the reopening of schools and take action to make them as safe as possible, including through renewed investments in proven infection prevention measures like clean water and soap in every school around the world.” 

Some 24 million children are at risk of dropping out of school due to the pandemic, the report said, which would reverse global progress made on school enrollment. 

School feeding programmes can provide incentives for the most vulnerable students to return to the classroom, especially girls and those from the poorest and most marginalized communities. 

Jeopardizing the future 

“Missing out on nutritious school meals is jeopardizing the futures of millions of the world’s poorest children. We risk losing a whole generation”, said David Beasley, the WFP Executive Director.  

“We must support governments to safely reopen schools and start feeding these children again. For many, the nutritious meal they get in school is the only food they will receive all day.” 

WFP has been supporting governments to adapt their school meals programmes with more than 70 countries delivering take-home rations, cash transfers or food vouchers during school closures. 

Additionally, more than 13 million children received WFP school-based support during the first nine months of 2020, compared to 17.3 million the previous year.

Coronavirus Portal & News Updates

Readers can find information and guidance on the outbreak of the novel coronavirus (2019-nCoV) from the UN, World Health Organization and UN agencies here. For daily news updates from UN News, click here.

Central African Republic: Rights expert welcomes transfer of war crimes suspect to ICC

CAR authorities surrendered Mahamat Said Abdel Kani, a commander of the Séléka rebel coalition, to the court on Sunday, on account of an arrest warrant issued under seal on 7 January  . 

Mr. Said is suspected of being responsible for war crimes and crimes against humanity, including torture, persecution and enforced disappearance, allegedly committed in the capital, Bangui, in 2013. 

‘A strong message’ 

“The transfer of Mahamat Said Abdel Kani on 24 January sends a strong message. Justice is an essential pillar of the ongoing peace and reconciliation process and the construction of the rule of law”, said Yao Agbetse, UN Independent Expert on the situation of human rights in the CAR. 

Mr. Said will make his first appearance before the ICC on Thursday.  

The development is taking place against the backdrop of renewed unrest in the CAR surrounding elections in December. 

Last week, the head of the UN mission in the country appealed to the Security Council for more peacekeepers amid escalating attacks by an alliance of armed groups known as the Coalition of Patriots for Change (CPC).    

The CAR has had a history of political instability, but has been mired in violence since 2013 when the Séléka, a mainly Muslim coalition, seized power from former President, François Bozizé. Thousands were killed and displaced in fighting between the group and mainly Christian militias, known as Anti-Balaka.  

Two members of Anti-Balaka are currently on trial at the ICC, which is based in The Hague, in The Netherlands. 

Alfred Yekatom was surrendered to the court in November 2018, and Patrice-Edouard Ngaïssona was transferred there three months later. They were allegedly responsible for crimes that include murder, torture, attacks against civilians, and recruiting child soldiers. 

The ICC has combined their cases “to enhance the fairness and expeditiousness of the proceedings”, including by avoiding duplication of evidence and excessive impact on witnesses and victims. 

In pursuit of justice

ICC Prosecutor Fatou Bensouda welcomed Mr. Said’s arrest in a statement issued a day after his handover.

“As I have previously stated, my Office will relentlessly pursue justice  for the victims of atrocity crimes in CAR,” she said.

“During my term as Prosecutor, our purpose has been clear. Investigations are, by definition, quiet, confidential processes, but my Office has been hard at work all along, unflinching in its drive to do what it can, in a balanced and committed manner, to bring the perpetrators to justice, notwithstanding the challenges. Yesterday’s announcement is another manifestation of that commitment.” 

Transferring Mr. Said to the ICC is part of the fight against impunity and the need for justice for victims of massive human rights violations in the CAR, according to Mr. Agbetse, the UN expert. 

“I call on the Central African Republic authorities to create conditions that will put an end to impunity and bring justice to the victims”, he said. 

Mr. Agbetse encouraged further investigations of people and entities listed by the UN Security Council Sanctions Committee. He also supported ongoing investigations to arrest those allegedly responsible for violations, including the leaders of the CPC and their supporters. 

Role of independent experts

As an Independent Expert, Mr. Agbetse was appointed by the UN Human Rights Council and is not a UN staff member, nor does he receive a salary from the Organization.

Tigray’s children in crisis and beyond reach, after months of conflict: UNICEF

In an alert on Wednesday, the agency’s Executive Director, Henrietta Fore, said that the “very little” that was known about the impact of the conflict from only “limited partner accounts and UN assessments, (was) deeply troubling”.

She added: “Our concern is that what we don’t know, could be even more disturbing. For 12 weeks, the international humanitarian community has had very limited access to conflict-affected populations across most of Tigray.”

The warning comes almost two weeks since UNICEF and partners dispatched 29 trucks filled with emergency nutrition, health, and protection supplies into Tigray, where central Government soldiers have confronted Tigray People’s Liberation Front (TPLF) forces.

Greater support needed

That convoy was “a step in the right direction, but nowhere near the level of access and scale of support that is actually needed”, Ms. Fore said.

Citing reports of 300 unaccompanied or separated children among the more than 57,000 people who have fled to neighbouring Sudan, the UNICEF chief said that there were potentially many more among the approximately 280,000 internally displaced in Tigray, Amhara and Afar regions.

Ms. Fore warned that immunizations stopped across Tigray while basic services including health facilities have been damaged, destroyed and stripped of essential supplies.

There is also little fuel to operate water and sanitation systems, the UNICEF chief noted, before underscoring dire malnutrition levels among babies and toddlers.

’70,000 children at risk’

“One assessment conducted by partners in early January in the Shire area showed rates of severe acute malnutrition of up to 10 per cent among children below the age of five”, she said. “This is far above WHO’s emergency threshold of three per cent and could potentially put the lives of up to 70,000 children at risk.” 

According to UNICEF, within Tigray more widely, the global acute malnutrition level has risen to 34 per cent, raising fears that affected children could eventually succumb to life-threatening malnutrition.

“Beyond delivering supplies, restoring essential services is key”, Ms. Fore maintained. “For that to happen, salaries of civil servants need to be paid and access for humanitarian staff granted, to help regional authorities assess the growing needs, identify priorities and deliver much-needed services.”

It was up to all parties to the conflict to respect their “fundamental obligation” to provide “rapid, unimpeded and sustained access to civilians in need of assistance”, the UNICEF Executive Director insisted, in a call for unconditional access for personnel and goods.

“The one thing we do know is that every additional day of waiting for help will only worsen children’s suffering.”

Tens of thousands in northwest Syria lose shelter after floods inundate camps

At least 196 IDP sites in Idlib and Aleppo reportedly sustained damage, with many roads leading to the camps cut off by heavy rains between 14 and 20 January, the Office said in a humanitarian bulletin. 

At least 67,600 have reportedly been affected, and more than 3,760 tents destroyed,with over 7,720 damaged. 

“Thousands of people have been temporarily relocated, many requiring shelter, food, and non-food item support immediately, and in the long term”, OCHA said. 

“The rain and low temperatures highlight the continued need for fuel and heating, winter clothes, blankets, food, livelihoods, and water, sanitation and hygiene”, it added. 

Risk of fire outbreaks 

Without sufficient “winterization” – preparing shelters and camps to withstand the harsh conditions and keep occupants warm – people in need could resort to negative coping mechanisms, such as burning unsafe materials for heat, raising the risk of fire outbreaks and toxic fumes, OCHA said. 

The likelihood of accidental fires is increased by challenges in accessing safe fuels, as a result of scarcity and high prices of fuel as well as the general economic deterioration in northwest Syria, it added.  

In the past month, some 17 fire incidents were reported that affected 28 households, destroyed 28 tents, resulting in one death and seven injuries. 

Ongoing hostilities 

Meanwhile, ongoing fighting in the region continues to take a toll on civilians, especially near near the M4 and M5 highways – two key arteries linking the capital Damascus with Aleppo city and much of northern Syria. 

A number of civilian casualties – including children – have been reported due to artillery shelling or improvised explosive devices (IEDs) or unexploded ordinances (UXOs). Some incidents occurred in residential areas or at local markets, raising risk for civilians, OCHA said. 

UNICEF/Khaled Akacha
A child stands next to a woman as she makes a makeshift wall to prevent floodwater from entering her tent at an IDP camp in north-west Syria, in January 2021.

Massive crisis and extensive needs 

Continued hostilities, new and protracted displacement and a sustained erosion of communities’ resilience after a decade of conflict, has left millions in desperate need of assistance. 

Across Syria, an estimated 13 million people – over 70 per cent of the population – are expected to require aid in 2021. The UN estimates that 10.5 million people will be targeted with humanitarian assistance through the year at a cost of $4.2 billion, which is a 10 per cent increase compared to 2020. 

Climate change is a ‘global emergency’, people say in biggest ever climate poll

Described as the biggest climate survey yet conducted, UN Development Programme (UNDP)’s “People’s Climate Vote” poll also showed that people supported more comprehensive climate policies to respond to the challenges. The survey covered 50 countries with over half the world’s population.

“The results of the survey clearly illustrate that urgent climate action has broad support amongst people around the globe, across nationalities, age, gender and education level,” Achim Steiner, UNDP Administrator said in a news release. 

The poll also showed “how” people want their policymakers to tackle the climate crisis. 

“From climate-friendly farming to protecting nature, and investing in a green recovery from COVID-19, the survey brings the voice of the people to the forefront of the climate debate. It signals ways in which countries can move forward with public support as we work together to tackle this enormous challenge,” Mr. Steiner added. 

‘Biggest survey ever’ on climate change 

UNDP said that the poll was the world’s biggest survey ever of public opinion on climate change. It was conducted as countries prepare for negotiations at November’s COP26, the 26th session of Conference of the Parties to the UN Framework Convention on Climate Change (UNFCCC). 

The survey asked respondents if climate change was a global emergency and whether they supported 18 key climate policies across six action areas: economy, energy, transport, food and farms, nature, and protecting people.  

Its target audience of 1.2 million included over half a million people under the age of 18, a key constituency on climate change that is typically unable to vote yet in regular elections. Innovations, such as distribution across mobile gaming networks, were used to ensure that the young audience were reached.  

According to UNDP, polling experts at the University of Oxford weighted the huge sample to make it representative of the age, gender, and education population profiles of the countries in the survey, resulting in small margins of error (+/- 2 per cent). 

People want broad climate policies 

The results showed that people supported “broad climate policies”, beyond the current situation, UNDP said. 

For instance, in eight of the ten survey countries with the highest emissions from the power sector, majority backed more renewable energy. In four out of five countries with the highest emissions from land-use change and enough data on policy preferences, the majority supported conserving forests and land. Nine out of ten of the countries with the most urbanized populations backed more use of clean electric cars and buses, or bicycles.   

The survey also found a direct link between a person’s level of education and their desire for climate action, according to UNDP. 

There was very high recognition of the climate emergency among those who had attended university or college in all countries, from lower-income countries such as Bhutan (82 per cent) and Democratic Republic of the Congo (82 per cent), to wealthy countries like France (87 per cent) and Japan (82 per cent).  

Findings also revealed that while younger people (under 18) were more likely to say climate change is an emergency, other age groups were not far behind, with 65 per cent aged 18-35; 66 per cent aged 36-59; and 58 per cent over 60, expressing affirmation. 

“[This] illustrated how widely held this view has become,” said UNDP. 

US witnessed ‘echoes of the Holocaust’ during breach of the Capitol, says concentration camp survivor 

Born in Berlin in 1930, she was only three years old when Hitler came to power and the persecution of the Jews in Germany began. 

Speaking at a virtual ceremony marking the International Day of Commemoration in memory of the victims of the Holocaust, Dr. Butter said the events that unfolded with the storming of the Capitol, showed that “democracy is vulnerable, and we cannot take anything for granted”. 

“It is up to us, to the people, to preserve and protect our democratic institutions and our Constitution”, she stated, which is why she believes that everyone in the US needs to be educated about what took place during the Holocaust, from those who survived it. 

“We have that responsibility to be active citizens, to confront hatred, and to confront the violations of our democracy and in that way, it can be preserved and protected”, she said.  

Heartbreaking account 

Dr. Butter told of how her family fled to Amsterdam to escape the Nazis, but just two years later, the Nazis invaded the Netherlands, and the “persecution of the Jews escalated”. 

“We were deported to two concentration camps”, she said. “First a German concentration camp in Holland, and then to Bergen-Belsen in Germany because my father had managed to apply for Ecuadorian passports thinking that that might save our lives”.  

After one grueling year in Bergen-Belsen, their Ecuadorian passports enabled them to be included in a Nazi-administered prisoner-exchange programme.  

“But then, sadly my father died on the train to Switzerland and when we arrived in Switzerland, my mother and my brother were hospitalized immediately”, she recalled. 

A painful separation 

Separated from her family, the then 14-year-old was sent to a refugee camp in Algiers for almost a year, before arriving in the US in 1945. 

“I was separated from my mother and my brother for eighteen months before we were reunited in New York to start a new life”, she said. “I’ve lived in the United States ever since and was lucky to take advantage of so many opportunities.” 

Speaking out 

Dr. Butter acknowledged that it took 40 years before she was able to follow the guidance of Elie Wiesel, who considered that providing testimony and bearing witnesses was the “duty” of all survivors. 

Since the late 1980s, she has been teaching students about the Holocaust and the lessons she learned during those traumatic years, affirming the need never to become numb to what is happening in the here and now.  

“We have to continue and be awake and act,” she said. “It’s very easy to get immersed in the day-to-day, but there are a lot of things that are happening around us and it’s really important to speak up”. 

‘Start from the Holocaust’  

According to Israeli Professor, Yehuda Bauer, the Holocaust was an “unprecedented genocide…because of its global form”. 

“Jews were intended to be annihilated all over the world”, not only in Europe, he said. 

The professor warned that it was “a precedent” that can be repeated, “so, when we deal with mass atrocity hate crimes today, with genocides today, we need to start from the Holocaust…not just for remembering but acting in accordance with the history that we are witnesses of”.  

“We have to remember it, and we have to act in accordance with the lessons that we have learned from it”, stressed Professor Bauer. 

Satellite on Jewish history 

Ari Folman who also spoke during the day of online commemoration, is the son of Holocaust survivors who met and married in the Lodz ghetto. 

His award-winning animated documentary Waltz with Bashir, recounts the story at the Łódź ghetto in September 1942, where for three days, 15,000 Jewish children were deported to concentration camps – never to return. 

Mr. Folman quoted the very last sentence of the film in which an elderly Holocaust survivor from Łódź says: “Once we are all gone from this world, all the Holocaust survivors, the point of view that would be taken, looking back at the events, will be so far away – it will be like looking from a satellite on Jewish history in World War Two”. 

He said that that was the reason why he was dedicating eight years of his life to “finding new dimensions, new ways of storytelling in regards of the Holocaust”.  

He said that for him, it was comics and animation that can be used for educational purposes, “all over the world, to keep the story alive.”

Gamba ‘deeply concerned’ over COVID impact on children caught in conflict

Special Representative Virginia Gamba presented her latest report to the UN Human Rights Council, which shows COVID-19 response has made these children more vulnerable to grave violations.   

Their rights to education and health, and access to justice, social services and humanitarian aid, have also been restricted. 

“I am deeply concerned about the adverse impact of the COVID-19 pandemic on children affected by armed conflict”, she said, urging countries to ensure that child protection services can continue during the crisis.  

No military use of schools 

Ms. Gamba also stressed the need for warring parties to respect schools and health facilities, and the people who work in them. 

“The military use of schools can never be justified, including when buildings are temporarily closed due to lockdowns, particularly in countries with fragile education systems where education is a scarce commodity”, she emphasized. 

The report further revealed that although children are disproportionately affected by conflict, they are sidelined in transitional justice processes. 

This is occurring even though the Convention on the Rights of the Child, the most ratified human rights treaty in history, includes an Optional Protocol (OPAC) to protect boys and girls from recruitment and use in hostilities.  

Grave violations are preventable 

Ms. Gamba said children must be included in transitional justice processes as their participation is critical to breaking intergenerational cycles of violence and preventing future violations. 

“Grave violations of children’s rights are not inevitable by-products of war: they are preventable”, she added. 

“I call upon Member States that have not done so, to become a party to the OPAC and to enact national legislation and policies to prohibit and criminalize the recruitment and use of children by armed forces and armed groups.” 

The UN Special Representatives also urged all parties to conflict to endorse the Secretary-General’s appeal for a global ceasefire during the pandemic.

“As the vulnerability of boys and girls living amidst hostilities is exacerbated by the COVID-19 pandemic, processes such as ceasefires, peace negotiations, and security sector reform are opportunities to protect children,” she said.

Action and engagement 

Her report also showcased progress to end and prevent grave violations against children. 

Key achievements in 2020 included a Child Protection Code in the Central African Republic which criminalizes recruitment and upholds that children associated with armed groups are to be considered as victims.  In Myanmar, the UN signed a Joint Action Plan with the Democratic Karen Benevolent Army, marking a first for armed groups in the country. 

Ongoing UN engagement, supported by the Special Representative for Children and Armed Conflict, also led to the release of children by parties to conflict in Myanmar and in other countries such as the Democratic Republic of the Congo, Somalia, Syria and Yemen. 

 

Stand against antisemitism with the ‘utmost determination’ – German Chancellor Merkel

During the first Commemoration in Memory of the Victims of the Holocaust, organized jointly by the International Holocaust Remembrance Alliance, the UN and the UN Educational, Scientific and Cultural Organization (UNESCO), Angela Merkel added that antisemitism must be thwarted, “be it open or veiled, and against denial or diminishing of the Holocaust”. 

“We honour the victims of the Holocaust by remembering them and by learning from their plight. That is our everlasting responsibility – for today’s and future generations”, she stated, in her video message to the powerful online event, translated from German.  

‘Beyond belief’ 

On 27 January 1945, exactly 76 years ago, the extermination camp at Auschwitz-Birkenau was liberated.  

“What happened there and in many other places where atrocities were committed during the National Socialist period, is and remains beyond belief”, Ms. Merkel said. 

She expressed deep shame over the catastrophic killing of millions of European Jews by Nazi Germany – known in Hebrew as the Shoah – and of “the betrayal of all civilized values, perpetrated under the National Socialist regime”. 

The German Chancellor emphasized that “it is, and remains, Germany’s everlasting responsibility” to remember the Holocaust and to commemorate the victims: the European Jews, Sinti and Roma, political prisoners and Polish intelligentsia, prisoners of war, resistance fighters, homosexuals, people with disabilities, and “countless other men, women and children, who were humiliated, persecuted, tortured and murdered”. 

“We must never forget these people and their fates”, she stressed. 

Ms. Merkel concluded her address with special thanks to the survivors who “muster the strength” to tell the story of their lives.  

“Their first-hand accounts show us just how vulnerable human dignity is and how easily the values that underpin peaceful coexistence can be violated”, she said. 

Resurgence of antisemitism 

Noting that antisemitism found its most horrific expression in the Holocaust, Secretary-General António Guterres said that the “universal revulsion at this crime” was one event leading to the UN’s founding and drawing up of the Universal Declaration of Human Rights. 

“But it did not end”, he said. “Indeed, today antisemitism is resurgent in many places around the world”.  

As the number of Holocaust survivors diminishes every year, white supremacists and neo-Nazis intensify their efforts to deny, distort and rewrite history including the Holocaust, the UN chief observed.  

In Europe, the United States and elsewhere, “white supremacists are organizing and recruiting across borders, shamelessly flaunting the symbols of the Nazis and their murderous ambitions”, he said.  

“We saw shocking examples in this nation’s capital in recent weeks”, Mr. Guterres attested, referring to the breach of the US Capitol building in Washington DC by violent extremists on 6 January, where some were caught on camera wearing Nazi symbols, including tributes to the Auschwitz concentration camp.  

He pointed to the COVID-19 pandemic as giving them “new opportunities to exploit social turmoil, turn people against each other and target minorities, based on religion, race, ethnicity, nationality, sexual orientation, disability and immigration status”.  

<!–

–> <!–

–>

‘No vaccine for antisemitism’ 

The UN chief warned that after decades in the shadows, neo-Nazis and their ideas are “gaining currency and even a kind of respectability”. 

He noted that in some countries, their messages and ideology can be heard in debates between mainstream political parties and in others they have infiltrated police and state security services.  

Stressing the need to “urgently strengthen our joint efforts” against the dangers they pose, the Secretary-General said, “there is no vaccine for antisemitism and xenophobia”.  

“The most effective weapon remains the facts and the truth”, the UN chief underscored. 

Humanity ‘forever shaken’ 

Reminding viewers and participants how the Holocaust has “forever shaken the foundations of our common humanity”, UNESCO chief Audrey Azoulay recounted that when the Soviet soldiers liberated the Auschwitz-Birkenau camp, they found some seven thousand emaciated detainees, many of whom perished in the following days.   

In addition to the corpses, executed after the Nazis forced prisoners to take part in a “death march”, she said that along with the remaining gas chambers, they also discovered traces of the Nazis’ “merciless system”. 

“Today, as hateful voices continue to rise, denying or distorting the implacable reality of these facts, we have a universal responsibility to remember each and every individual whom the Nazis sought to erase from the face of the earth”, the UNESCO chief said.   

Past shapes future 

Ms. Azoulay upheld the importance of remembering the “communities and cultures that were destroyed” and underlined the need to protect against the ideas that led to the genocide, and human rights overall. 

“The ways we remember and understand the past will shape our future”, she said, which is why UNESCO is “resolute in its commitment” to educating about the causes and consequences of the Holocaust, “preventing antisemitism in its contemporary guise” and averting future atrocities from happening.   

In this way the resilience of all people can be strengthened against prejudice and the universal principles of justice, dialogue and solidarity that underpin the Organization’s mandate be maintained. 

“I call upon all Member States and civil society organizations to engage in further efforts to promote education, documentation and research on these unprecedented events, which continue to be a blight on the world’s conscience”, the UNESCO chief said.

Italy failed to rescue over 200 migrants in 2013 Mediterranean disaster, UN rights body finds

In a decision published on Wednesday, the Human Rights Committee – an independent expert body that monitors States’ compliance with the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights – said that Italy failed to respond promptly to various distress calls from the sinking boat, which was carrying more than 400 adults and children. 

Italy also failed to explain the delay in dispatching its naval vessel, ITS Libra, which was located only about an hour away from the scene, the Committee said in a news release. 

The complaint 

The Committee’s decision responded to a joint complaint lodged by four survivors – three Syrians and a Palestine national – who lost their families in the accident. The plaintiffs recounted the incidents of 10 October 2013, including the vessel’s plea to Italian authorities for urgent assistance.  

Several hours later, Italian authorities told the vessel that it was in the Maltese search and rescue zone, and only provided them with a phone number of Malta’s Rescue Coordination Centre. By the time a Maltese patrol boat arrived, the vessel had already capsized, and an Italian naval ship was dispatched only after an urgent request from Malta. 

As a result of the delayed action, more than 200 people, including 60 children, drowned, the committee states. 

According to the news release, some surviving migrants sought justice in Italian courts, and took their case to the Human Rights Committee as Italy failed to take appropriate measures to save their relatives, thus violating their right to life. 

A parallel claim brought against Malta was rejected by the Committee as the plaintiffs did not bring legal proceedings before courts in Malta, which is one of the requirements, prior to filing their case to the Human Rights Committee. 

‘A complex case’ 

Hélène Tigroudja, a member of the Human Rights Committee said that the case was a “complex” one. 

“The accident happened in the international waters within the Maltese search and rescue zone but the location was indeed closest to Italy and to one of its naval ships. Had the Italian authorities immediately directed its naval ship and coast guard boats after the distress calls, the rescue would have reached the vessel, at the latest, two hours before it sank.” 

Ms. Tigroudja added that under the international law of the sea, State parties are required to take steps to protect the lives of all individuals who find themselves in a situation of distress at sea.  

“Even though the sinking vessel was not located in Italy’s search and rescue zone, the Italian authority had a duty to support the search and rescue mission to save the lives of the migrants. Italy’s delayed action had a direct impact on the loss of hundreds of lives.”  

In its decision, the Committee also urged Italy to conduct an independent and timely investigation and to prosecute those responsible; and called on Italy and other countries involved in the tragedy to provide effective remedy to those who lost their families in the accident. 

The disaster 

At around 1am on 10 October 2013, a fishing boat carrying more than 400 migrants – including children – departed from Libya for Italy. A few hours later, the vessel started sinking in international waters. 

According to the joint complaint, one of those on board the vessel called the Italian number for emergencies at sea, saying they were sinking and forwarding the boat’s coordinates. 

Over the next few hours, the person tried several times, only to be told after 1pm that as they were in the Maltese search and rescue zone and thus the Italian authorities had forwarded their distress call to the Maltese authority. In spite of the emergency, the Italian operator only passed on to them the phone number of Malta’s Rescue Coordination Centre. 

The migrants made several, increasingly desperate phone calls, but when a Maltese patrol boat arrived at the scene at 5:50pm, the vessel had already capsized. As per Malta’s urgent request, Italy finally instructed its navy ship ITS Libra, which was in the boat’s vicinity, to come to the rescue, after 6pm.

Get help now

Send a message with a description of your problem and possible ways of assistance and we will contact you as soon as we consider your problem.

    [recaptcha class:captcha]